How Long Should You Own a House Before Selling?

by | Nov 21, 2021 | Selling

Thinking about buying or selling a home?

Contact an expert agent for a free, no-obligation consultation today!

Buying a home is often the biggest purchase of a person’s life. Thus, it’s no surprise that homeowners choose to stay put in their houses for a fairly long time. According to Zillow, the average home buyer stays in their house for 13 years. However there are always situations that might come up in the short term that could affect your long term needs. So, how long should you own a house before selling? This article helps homeowners understand the data behind the ideal time to own your home, while also making the best decision for your personal situation.

What are reasons for selling your house sooner than expected?

You might consider selling your house for a variety of reasons relatively soon after you buy a house.

Job relocation: You might get a new job that makes it necessary for you to live somewhere else, whether it’s another city, state, or even country. In this case, it might make sense for you to sell your home rather than carry a second mortgage.

Health emergency: It’s possible you or somebody else in your family falls ill and that may require moving for better medical treatment, or you just don’t have the ability to take care of your house anymore. 

Buyer’s remorse: After making your house purchase, you might decide after a little time of living in it that this house just isn’t the right house for you. 

Family changes: Maybe you’re planning to have a new baby in the family, or maybe (heaven forbid) somebody has died, among other things. This might require a change in space, whether you’re adding more room or downsizing.

How long should you own a home before selling: Profit

Perhaps you’ve taken a look at the real estate market, and you’re already expecting to turn a profit with a good sale price from selling your house. Some folks understand this situation even before they buy. In this case, it might make good financial sense to sell your house and not work on building your equity. There are 3 reasons why this might work out.

  • You made significant renovations in a short period of time to increase your home’s resale value. This is known as “house flipping.”
  • Home values in your neighborhood shot up dramatically. This could be the result of a new development in your area or a big company moving in nearby.
  • You somehow got a good deal initially. For example, if you originally bought your home as a foreclosure or a short sale and can sell it under normal circumstances, you might turn a profit.

Financial crisis: What if your mortgage payments or your property taxes are more expensive than you thought, or what if you lose your job? And of course, there are other financial reasons for selling your house quickly.

How soon can you sell your house without losing money? 

How long you stay in your house relates to the point at which you are breaking even or moving beyond that with regard to paying rent. There are some circumstances that make selling a home shortly after buying it a smart financial move. However, this is a somewhat rare occurrence and the decision to sell should not be taken lightly.

Breakeven horizon

Every real estate market has a different breakeven point. This determines whether it makes more sense to rent or to buy a house during a particular period of time. For example, if you purchased a house in the Raleigh area. Say you paid $300k for it, with a 20% downpayment, you would need to live in that house for at least 3 years before breaking even. This assumes your rent would have been $1,500 a month.

Additionally, the sooner you resell a house, the fewer financial benefits you’re going to see. Plus, in some cases, you could actually lose money. Since you’ll need to pay capital gains taxes, those can punish your finances.

We Make Buying & Selling Simple!

List your home for one low fee and/or buy and get thousands cash back.

Get Commission Free Realty

Capital gains taxes

One of the biggest pitfalls for buying a home and selling quickly is capital gains. If you own a house for longer than a year, and turn a profit on the sale, you’re looking at a capital gains tax rate of up to 20%, depending on your tax bracket.

If you sell your house in under a year, you’re looking at an even higher tax rate. Short-term gains are taxed at the same rate as your income. So, you could be paying as much as 37% in capital gains, if you’re in the highest income bracket.

Once you hit the 2 year mark, however, you’re eligible to exclude $250,000 (or $500,000 as a couple) in capital gains. This will likely exempt your entire profits from capital gains taxes.

Other expenses

And of course there are many other expenses to be wary of when you’re selling a house, whether it’s quickly or later on down the road. If your house is valued at $300k, you’ll need to consider: 

  • Staging costs – $3,000: Staging a home can help your home sell faster, which you may need to do well, if you need to sell your house quickly. 
  • Home repairs/renovations – $15,000: You’ll want to paint, fix minor issues to upgrade your house and make it appealing to buyers. 
  • Real estate commissions – $18,000. Typically the seller needs to pay for both the seller’s real estate agent and the buyer’s which can be 6% of the value of the house.
  • Seller concessions – $4,500: This could be any number of things, paying for the inspection etc. Fortunately, if you live in a seller’s market, this might not be as much of a concern. 
  • Closing costs – $3,000: Some closing costs are typically paid by the seller, even in a buyer’s market. 
  • Moving costs – $2,000: Cost to hire movers, trucks, buy boxes, and so on. 
  • Transition costs – $2,000: Maybe you need to rent an apartment for a month while your other home sells, in which case, you’re spending more money again on rent. 

Mortgage prepayment penalty

Some mortgage lenders charge a prepayment penalty if you sell your home quickly after buying. It’s a way for lenders to get back some of the money they’ll lose on interest payments, since you’re paying your loan off so quickly. The amount you’ll have to pay depends on the terms of your loan, of course. It could be a percentage of your remaining loan balance (usually between 2% to 5%), a percentage of owed interest or a flat rate.

Most loans these days don’t have prepayment penalties however, and there are never prepayment penalties on FHA loans, for example. 

Negative buyer perception

Since listing history is readily available on sites like Zillow and on local MLS websites, buyers and their real estate agents can see when you purchased your house and what you paid for it. If you’re selling less than a year after buying, buyers might wonder if there’s something wrong with the place or maybe the neighborhood. And that could lead to fewer or lower offers. 

In conclusion

Unless you need to sell quickly for a specific reason or unless you see your way clear to turn a profit from the sale, it’s best to not sell your house too quickly and to stay in place for at least 2-3 years. You’ll start to accrue the benefits of owning versus buying, you’ll build equity, and if the real estate market rises in your area, your house value will also increase. 

Stay up to date on the latest market conditions

Get the best real estate advice from local experts in your inbox.

The information contained in this blog is for general information purposes only, and while believed to be accurate, Trelora assumes no legal responsibility for accuracy. Information provided within should not relied upon as legal advice. Please consult with your local advisors for independent information regarding availability and applicability in your market.